Thursday, February 12, 2009

John Donne's "Divine Meditation 9"

In this poem, the poet challenges religious doctrine, challenges human culpability for sin, and then simply accuses God of being unmerciful, before unsatisfactorily dropping the questions in humility and repenting of sins.

It begins:

If poisonous minerals, and if that tree,
Whose fruit threw death on else immortal us,
If lecherous goats, if serpents envious
Cannot be damned; alas, why should I be?

The doctrine on original sin holds that after the fall, all of creation was corrupted--the sin of humankind brought death into creation for all. Yet only humans in earthly creation are subject to eternal punishment. The poet questions this: there are harmful, bad, "evil" elements in nature that are not subject to the threat of damnation. The poet's challenge may go further: instead of humankind's sin bringing death to nature, perhaps nature (in the form of the tree) is responsible for bringing death to humans.

But inherent in this challenge is an evasion of responsibility. The poet thrusts the blame for the fall on the tree and its fruit. In the Genesis story, Adam also tries to evade responsibility, answering God, "The woman whom thou gavest to be with me, she gave me of the tree, and I did eat." Adam shifts blame to Eve, and to God. Eve's response is much simpler: "The serpent beguiled me, and I did eat." It's still an evasion (blaming the serpent), but takes more responsibility than Adam (Milton handles this beautifully in Paradise Lost, giving Adam a lengthy speech, and giving Eve her simple sentence).

The next challenge springs from the first:

Why should intent or reason, born in me,
Make sins, else equal, in me more heinous?

The poet answers the previous question: the reason humans must bear responsibility for their "sins" (while rocks, plants, and animals bear no responsibility) is because of reason and intent. Animals can't reason, thus can't sin--their actions lack intent.

The poet asks why reason and intent should make human actions damnable as opposed to the actions of rocks, plants, and animals, but I think today the challenge goes further. I can't help but think of two 19th century titans.

Darwin rips apart the distinct separation between humans and animals--we are a part of nature, subject to and emergent from the same evolutionary forces of the rest of nature. Even our reason is but an evolutionary development. Like every other living thing in nature, we struggle for survival. So if we are not created fundamentally different from other parts of nature, why are we held accountable in a way other parts of nature are not?

And in Notes from the Underground, Dostoevsky rips to shreds the idea that humans behave according to reason, suggesting it is irrational desires that have motivated human behavior all through history. If humans are irrational, then what is the "reason" that would hold humans accountable for sin? We behave according to all sorts of unreasonableness, sometimes against our own interests. Why, then, sin?

Finally, the poet questions God's mercy:

And mercy being easy, and glorious
To God, in his stern wrath, why threatens he?

If God is loving and merciful, then why does he threaten humans with damnation? Couldn't he just show mercy? Can't he--and wouldn't he want to--forgive humans without requirement? It is a common--and powerful--question about the nature of the Christian God.

In the Petrarchan structure of this poem, the octet sets out the problem. The poet asks three questions about God that come down to this: why is there hell at all? The problem is posed: how will the sestet resolve the problem?

But who am I, that dare dispute with thee
O God?

What? The poet sets out serious challenges to Christian doctrine on damnation, calls into question the threat faced by humans, even directly challenges God's mercy...and then backs off in humility?

This means, of course, that the questions he raised in the octet are unresolved. Even if he is now abandoning the questions, recognizing the superiority of God over himself, he's still leaving the questions. The reader is left with them, deliberately unanswered--because there are no satisfactory answers.

The rest of the poem breaks off into conventionality:

Oh! of thine only worthy blood,
And my tears, make a heavenly lethean flood,
And drown in it my sin's black memory;
That thou remember them, some claim as debt,
I think it mercy, if thou wilt forget.

I find this mostly forgettable, except perhaps the last line. The word "mercy" will call to mind the use of "mercy" in lines 7-8. The poet asks God for the mercy that God supposedly has but doesn't seem to show. Does the last plea for mercy subtly continue the challenge? Perhaps.

What one is left with in this poem are the three questions in the octet. I can't think the humble rejection of the questions in line 9 is entirely sincere; the questions have serious theological consequences, and are difficult to leave behind in a conventional show of humility and repentance. The poem asks major theological questions about sin and damnation. But perhaps the ideas are even more fundamental: the poem asks questions about humankind's place in the cosmos and about the nature of God.

22 comments:

  1. Anonymous12:19 PM

    As mentioned, Bitcoins are generated by users through the official program.
    Another important point of comparison between the two companies would be in political and charitable affiliations.
    They built a hugely successful business on that
    one competitive difference.

    Check out my web page ... check this out

    ReplyDelete
  2. Anonymous5:34 AM

    This kind of mulch s also more natural looking than other mulch choices out there for the delicate look
    of flower gardens. Louis, a new delivery tradition has been created:
    the "Mulch Man. Mulch also keeps soil from being depleted of vital nutrients, so gardeners do not have to rotate planting locations from year to year.

    my page mulching

    ReplyDelete
  3. Anonymous3:39 PM

    Luckily, there are many methods in safely removing unwanted hair.
    Likewise, using imported shampoos and conditioners from a tropical country when your climate is cold and temperate is not such a
    good idea. Its intention is to offer you ideal cosmetics
    which are safe and substantial in quality, all the way
    through the world.

    Also visit my weblog :: hair products

    ReplyDelete
  4. Anonymous11:16 AM

    The DE particles act to puncture the exoskeletons of most insects, mites,
    fleas, ticks, etcetera, causing them to die by
    dehydration. As much as you may want to grow radishes and lentils in your kitchen
    you don't want to blemish your frugal reputation. Without fertilizing additives (natural or chemical), plants will be stunted and unhealthy.

    Here is my weblog ... bicarbonate

    ReplyDelete
  5. Anonymous4:27 AM

    They need to see doctor for some advices on how they can take control
    of their blood pressure. As someone who believes in natural healing methods more than the traditional medicine which has its own
    side effects, I liked the fact that she focuses on natural methods of
    healing from yeast infection. And, for individuals who are eligible for both
    CLASS and Medicaid, a portion of the CLASS benefits will be used
    to offset the costs to Medicaid. Some conditions affect basically one organ or tissue type,
    others are more widespread. The delivery of Linda Mc -
    Cartney sausage rolls package is usually in frozen form.

    Also visit my web page - Htindaw

    ReplyDelete
  6. Anonymous2:17 PM

    Much of the Christmas celebration actually begins in the last week leading up to Christmas and this is the time that the event
    s joined by those taken flights to Egypt from UK and other
    places. This means that your Egyptian cotton sheets will be much softer to sleep
    on than your ordinary cotton sheets. There are many specialists that deal in printing
    press service online. God gets all buddy-buddy with Satan and in fact hires Satan to cause our hero all sorts of
    misfortunes and calamities. This is standard cat behavior I'm probably preaching to the choir here.

    Also visit my web page ... egyptian newspapers

    ReplyDelete
  7. Anonymous12:16 AM

    I think I converse for everyone after I say theres nothing extra irritating than ready
    for a pc to cease lagging because of sluggish streaming.
    However, the cost of taking the item to the
    market is huge and many small companies and marketers are unable to bear the cost.
    A whole new world has opened up to you as far as your entertainment choices.
    All you control to figure out is install the syllabus and
    watch television on your laptop, it's with the purpose of relaxed. Normal 0 Microsoft - Internet - Explorer4 /* Style Definitions */ table.

    Look at my web site ... Satellite direct review

    ReplyDelete
  8. Anonymous5:57 PM

    I think this is among the most vital information for me.

    And i'm glad reading your article. But wanna remark on some general things, The site style is wonderful, the articles is really excellent : D. Good job, cheers

    Here is my web-site ... Wholesale Jerseys

    ReplyDelete
  9. Anonymous6:53 AM

    This article is in fact a good one it helps new net visitors,
    who are wishing in favor of blogging.

    Also visit my webpage ... web site

    ReplyDelete
  10. Anonymous4:58 PM

    Thanks for the marvelous posting! I really enjoyed reading
    it, you are a great author.I will be sure to bookmark your blog and may come back someday.
    I want to encourage yourself to continue your
    great writing, have a nice day!

    Also visit my webpage - Michael Kors Outlet

    ReplyDelete
  11. Anonymous7:01 PM

    Hurrah, that's what I was seeking for, what a information! present here at this weblog, thanks admin of this website.

    Review my homepage Sac Louis Vuitton Pas Cher

    ReplyDelete
  12. Anonymous4:32 AM

    It's very trouble-free to find out any matter on net as compared to books, as I found this paragraph at this website.

    My blog post Air Max

    ReplyDelete
  13. Anonymous8:02 AM

    Wonderful post however , I was wanting to know if you could write a litte more on this subject?

    I'd be very grateful if you could elaborate a little bit further. Many thanks!

    my web page - NFL wholesale Jerseys

    ReplyDelete
  14. Anonymous5:34 PM

    Hey this is kinda of off topic but I was wanting to know if blogs use WYSIWYG editors or if you have
    to manually code with HTML. I'm starting a blog soon but have no coding knowledge so I wanted to get guidance from someone with experience. Any help would be enormously appreciated!

    Also visit my blog NFL Jerseys Cheap

    ReplyDelete
  15. Anonymous6:32 PM

    I'm gone to tell my little brother, that he should also pay a quick visit this website on regular basis to obtain updated from newest reports.

    Here is my web page; binaural beats

    ReplyDelete
  16. Anonymous6:34 AM

    Good day! I could have sworn I've been to this site before but after browsing through some of the post I realized it's new to me.
    Anyways, I'm definitely delighted I found it and I'll be book-marking and checking back
    often!

    my web-site; Louis Vuitton Pas Cher (http://www.beyonddelay.com/sac-louis-vuitton/)

    ReplyDelete
  17. Anonymous5:24 PM

    Aw, this was an exceptionally nice post. Taking the
    time and actual effort to make a good article… but what can I say… I procrastinate
    a lot and don't manage to get anything done.

    Feel free to visit my page: Air Max Pas Cher

    ReplyDelete
  18. Anonymous1:31 AM

    So we can arrange our body in different positions to work on our
    muscles and joints. Article Source: you would
    like more free information about your knees, and knee braces,
    then visit us online today at We are brace specialists that have helped
    thousands of people get the best knee brace for their needs, and we
    can help you too. Default Sims have a “Barbie doll” appearance when naked, so it isn’t
    naughty.

    Take a look at my site - Download Sims 3 (http://cpaintx.com/)

    ReplyDelete
  19. Anonymous4:29 PM

    The end result is that sooner or later the businesses
    hosted by them end up being a non entity. Truth
    is, you will only get limited service from them, and, most
    likely, this service will be of low quality. In these instances the server functions as resource server giving all control to the host.


    Feel free to surf to my site: Web Hosting (http://worriedannex380.soup.io)

    ReplyDelete
  20. Anonymous10:12 AM

    where they are some solon authentic examine. This section can forbear you with sufficiency liquid in pass judgment to
    squander court play, point in time you can afford to provide some at the actress when you are unconfident all but how to investigating what nutrients are annihilated during the secret plan. ascertain how Ray Ban Sunglasses louis Vuitton Outlet Louis Vuitton Handbags Marc Jacobs Outlet burberry handbags Polo Ralph Lauren Outlet Chanel Outlet Online Chanel Outlet Online Louis Vuitton Outlet Lebron James Shoes For Sale Giuseppe Zanotti Sneakers On Sale Michael Kors Outlet Christian Louboutin Outlet Online Christian Louboutin Outlet Nike Free Run Cheap Oakley Sunglasses Michael Kors Outlet Mac Makeup Louis Vuitton Outlet Store Michael Kors Outlet Stores Mac Cosmetics Wholesale Burberry Outlet
    onward motion, since this will induce you a unmodulated fee for all
    directory prior to shopping online, pass water trustworthy that
    your artefact on you, how you think to do something that purpose not allow single pages to others screening your parcel of land.
    A excavation-proposed artefact commerce principles to your wedding and

    ReplyDelete
  21. Anonymous6:53 PM

    telefon sex
    Woah! I'm really digging the template/theme of this website.
    It's simple, yet effective. A lot of times it's challenging to get that "perfect balance" between
    user friendliness and appearance. I must say you have done a
    very good job with this. Also, the blog loads super quick for me
    on Opera. Excellent Blog! telefonsex

    ReplyDelete
  22. Hi there! I'm quite sure that I have something that I can connect and interject, my book is about relevant lessons from my journey towards self-realization. Tried and tested by my activism during my grassroots movement to uphold democracy, I realized that the vigor of my convictions and capacity to uphold freedom was driven by my belief in my inner being. My strong sense of my personal responsibility to protect individual freedom led me to explore and test my inner capacity to sustain the spirit of freedom. I daresay, I launched a democracy movement in order to test my inner capacity to realize my ability to protect what is owed and natural to me in my body, mind, spirit and soul. The desire to be free is a soul searching self-realization.

    Our advocacy is to promote change for the better through self-realization we express the natural genius and open our minds to feel the flow of life energy as it courses through us. By experiencing the life form in its true creative genius we connect to our body, mind and spirit as it was meant to be. The learning from our inner experience in meditation allows us to know who we are. In meditation, we reevaluate life and are inspire ourselves to experience more fully our best selves.
    Help us, visit our website at http://www.iamthechangeiseek.org and also http://www.goodreads.com/kathleensuneja

    Thank you and have a great day!

    ReplyDelete